Monday, 24 March 2008

Who Wore Giambattista Valli Better?


We all remember that Elle US photoshoot in France were Victoria Beckham wore this Giambattista Valli gown.

Yesterday Rumer Willis also wore the same dress for her photoshoot in LA.

I hate to go against my girl, but you all know how much I disliked this shoot, and her hair and make-up here is just not to my liking, so Rumer wins for me.



Source & Source

10 comments:

Meg said...

Rumer, Vic's boobs ruined the dress.

Allie said...

Hands down it's Victoria. Rumer Willis drives me nuts!

matthew said...

EWWWWWW, rummer?, she is butt ugly. I didn't like that look on Victoria either, but she nailed it compared to rummer. Look at her pale skin. Ugh. Vicky is too hot to be compared to that...thing

Lanii Be Good said...

I'm opposite to Meg, there. I think Rumer's oddly-shaped, widely spread breasts make her look like a drag queen in this dress.
Posh looks like a woman - a demented one with unnaturally round boobs, but a woman nonetheless.

sunshine said...

Victoria looks shocked at this photo! what a messy hairstyle!
Yeah, willis got it, but she's kinda bit chubby, isnt she? or there's just something wrong with my eyes. lol

peach said...

Vic's boobs look ridiculous in this dress. Rumer doesn't look chubby to me, just like a normal woman.

Janie said...

I'm sorry to sound rude but lets face it the girl has inherited niether her mother nor her fathers looks . She is a big healthy carthorse of a girl , Victoria is delicate and feminine. There is no contest!

Posh said...

Victoria wins for me.
I've always liked her in this dress.
Rumer looks like a gay man and as Perez Hilton would say "A potato head".
I have to thank Fashion Critic for posting news everyday, this is the #1 site for all Beckham news.

THANKS! <3

Fashion Critic said...

Thanks Posh :)

Anonymous said...

Isn't the dress the problem since none of them succeed in sporting it? I love Giambattista Valli but this dress is a mess: I don't even get why this one is featured in Vogue/ELle etc...

However, the winner would be Rumer since the pose suggests she didn't know what to do with it and messed it up to spice it up. I love Victoria (I read your posts religiously)but I believe she takes clothing too seriously, without a shred of distance because she wished she had the same talent...

Don't get me wrong: she knows how to dress but she doesn't really have any fashion critical sense regarding designers; or why else would she agree to those photos for the Marc Jacobs ads...

Truth is: she is so desperate to be recognized by the fashion scene she would accept anything...
As Fashion critic pointed it out: she is used by Marc Jacobs whose inspiration (interest?) is dying but needs the shock factor to maintain the public's attention to not being dumped by LVMH!

According to me: MJ's days at Louis Vuitton are counted. Thanks God, Victoria will continue to dress and be around and about! I can't wait to see her again soon in your blog!